A gorgeously written tale of loss, corruption and mercy in the English countryside.
This is a beautifully written book that manages to show so many distinct and complementary levels, like an English trifle. I immediately fell in love with the narrator and his summer-drenched memories. Charles Ryder is visiting Brideshead again — now as a commander in the second world war — and recollecting his intense association with the Flyte family who lived there.
A promising artist, Charles begins as an uncorrupted youth who might have followed dull but cheerful Wilkins’ into a reputable profession. Instead he is befriended by the wealthy teddy bear carrying Sebastian Flyte and his entire life is swept up into a sort of narrator for the Flyte family’s drama.
The main theme is the destructive relationship between Charles, Sebastian and Julia. The beauty of the book is in the vagueness. Charles obviously loves Sebastian, but is it more than as a friend? When he later loves Julia, is it only as a socially acceptable proxy who resembles Sebastian?
But so many other things come to light – the troubled relationship with family, the effect of wealth without responsibility, the role of religion, the impact of adoration – the list goes on and on. There are endless questions in this book, endless ways to interpret and explore the impact of even minor characters like the little sister Cordelia.
My sympathy was with Charles at first, but he willfully ignores both logic and his own conscience. I felt that he ought to have known better, although we could argue his basically absentee father and dead mother do not adequately prepare him for standing up to the Flytes.
The charming Sebastian is the true tragedy and somehow more of a symbol than a real person. We are always forced to guess at his feelings and motives. He has so much potential, all wasted (or is it?) He uses alcohol and travel as a means of escaping himself. He is tortured by his love of being a young, self-indulgent and charming upper class heir against an enormous Roman Catholic pressure to be a saint and possibly a guilt of not having earned any of it himself.
While no one has a happy ending, perhaps each of the characters ends up in the place their actions have been leading them?
Nice review. I really liked this book.
LikeLike
Thanks! Appreciate you taking the time to comment! I really liked the book and I wish I had a good bookclub to discuss it with.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love Brideshead – I’m a sucker for such tragedies. Have you seen the BBC’s 2008 (I think it was) adaptation with Emma Thompson as Lady Marchmain and Matthew Goode as Charles Ryder?
LikeLike
Yeah such a beautiful story! I haven’t seen any adaptations yet, do you recommend the BBC one or the Jeremy Irons movie first?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve seen a lot of commentary saying that the 1981 TV series trumps the 2008 movie really hard. Given the sheer amount of Stuff to go through, it’s hardly surprising that a TV series should manage to be truer to the book.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I haven’t seen the Jeremy Irons film, but I do like the BBC version – such pretty actors, especially Sebastian (Ben Whishaw, I think).
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s really good to know. Now I know what I’m doing this weekend, binge watching vintage TV…
LikeLike